
The Cider House Rules, by John Irving, was very thought provoking; although, very long and sometimes hard to comprehend, it turned out to be a very good book. Homer Wells, who is the main character of the book, is an orphan at the St. Clouds orphanage in Maine. Homer gets adopted many times, but yet always ends up returning to St. Clouds. When he gets a little older, he really just gives up and accepts the orphanage as his home. Another main character is Dr. Wilbur Larch. Dr. Larch oversees the orphans and the hospital as well. Dr. Larch delivers some ladies their unwanted children and tries to find them homes. But it’s a secret that Dr. Larch is an abortionist too. As time passes, Dr. Larch starts teaching him many medical things and soon Homer can deliver or abort babies.
Also, there are some minor character such as Fuzzy Stone who is a sick orphan. Later in the book, Candy and Wally visit St. Clouds to have an abortion. Homer ends up falling for Candy. Also, each year, Homer posts a list of rules for the cider house designed to keep order and safety, even though the workers don’t like the rules. This book is hard to recap, but those are just the main points.
This book was a very tough read and I wouldn’t normally pick a book like this. Although, I’m glad I did because it ended up being pretty good. I didn’t think that abortion and single parenting could be a good topic for a book, but it was. It also had a very good story line. The biggest theme of this book is probably abortion. Later in the book when Dr. Larch dies, he asks homer to take over for him Homer and replies to him with a note saying “"1. I AM NOT A DOCTOR. 2. I BELIEVE THE FETUS HAS A SOUL. 3. I'M SORRY" (513). While reading the book, I had sympathy for the women that needed the abortions, and for the boy who believed that it was murder. This book was set time when abortion was illegal; But It's pretty clear in the book that Irving, the author, defiantly agrees that it’s a woman's right to choose. The book made me realize the impact that an abortion, non-abortion, can have on someone's life.
I don’t know if I can really recommend The Cider House Rules because I don’t think I would have ever chosen to just read it on my free time, but honestly, once the book got started it ended up being a very good read. Also, I defiantly wouldn’t recommend If you're strongly pro-life, you probably won't find yourself enjoying this book either. Abortion is too much of an ongoing issue throughout the book. But don’t get me wrong, abortion isn't the only weighty theme here, others being: war, morality, laws-and-rules, incest, family, death, violence; etc. Concluding, The Cider House Rules is about the many rules of life: some written, others not; some meant to be broken; some need to be created. It's about how our decisions affect both our own lives and the lives of others.
Irving, John. The Cider House Rules. New York: Modern Library, 1999.